Medizinonline Medizinonline
  • News
    • News
    • Market & Medicine
  • Patients
    • Disease patterns
    • Diagnostics
    • Therapy
  • Partner Content
    • Dermatology
      • Atopic dermatitis and psoriasis news
      • Dermatology News
    • Diabetes
      • Dia-Month Club – Type 2 Diabetes
      • Diabetes in Motion
      • Diabetes Podcasts
    • Gastroenterology
      • IBD matters
      • Forum Gastroenterology
      • Ozanimod: ulcerative colitis
      • Reflux Update
    • Immunology
      • Primary immunodeficiency – exchange of experience
    • Vaccinate
      • Herpes zoster
    • Infektiologie
    • Neurology
      • EXPERT ULTRASONIC: Introduction to ultrasound-guided injection
      • MS News
      • MS Therapy in Transition
    • Oncology
      • Swiss Oncology in motion
    • Orthopedics
      • Osteoporosis in motion
    • Phytotherapie
    • Practice Management
      • Aargau Cantonal Bank
      • Claraspital
    • Psychiatry
      • Geriatric Psychiatry
    • Rheumatology
  • Departments
    • Allergology and clinical immunology
    • General Internal Medicine
    • Anesthesiology
    • Angiology
    • Surgery
    • Dermatology and venereology
    • Endocrinology and Diabetology
    • Nutrition
    • Gastroenterology and Hepatology
    • Genetics
    • Geriatrics
    • Gynecology
    • Hematology
    • Infectiology
    • Cardiology
    • Nephrology
    • Neurology
    • Emergency and intensive care medicine
    • Nuclear Medicine
    • Oncology
    • Ophthalmology
    • ORL
    • Orthopedics
    • Pediatrics
    • Pharmacology and toxicology
    • Pharmaceutical medicine
    • Phlebology
    • Physical medicine and rehabilitation
    • Pneumology
    • Prevention and health care
    • Psychiatry and psychotherapy
    • Radiology
    • Forensic Medicine
    • Rheumatology
    • Sports Medicine
    • Traumatology and trauma surgery
    • Tropical and travel medicine
    • Urology
    • Dentistry
  • CME & Congresses
    • CME continuing education
    • Congress Reports
    • Congress calendar
  • Practice
    • Noctimed
    • Practice Management
    • Jobs
    • Interviews
  • Log In
  • Register
  • My account
  • Contact
  • English
    • Deutsch
    • Français
    • Italiano
    • Português
    • Español
  • Publications
  • Contact
  • Deutsch
  • English
  • Français
  • Italiano
  • Português
  • Español
Subscribe
Medizinonline Medizinonline
Medizinonline Medizinonline
  • News
    • News
    • Market & Medicine
  • Patienten
    • Krankheitsbilder
    • Diagnostik
    • Therapie
  • Partner Content
    • Dermatology
      • Atopic dermatitis and psoriasis news
      • Dermatology News
    • Diabetes
      • Dia-Month Club – Type 2 Diabetes
      • Diabetes in Motion
      • Diabetes Podcasts
    • Gastroenterology
      • IBD matters
      • Forum Gastroenterology
      • Ozanimod: ulcerative colitis
      • Reflux Update
    • Immunology
      • Primary immunodeficiency – exchange of experience
    • Vaccinate
      • Herpes zoster
    • Infektiologie
    • Neurology
      • EXPERT ULTRASONIC: Introduction to ultrasound-guided injection
      • MS News
      • MS Therapy in Transition
    • Oncology
      • Swiss Oncology in motion
    • Orthopedics
      • Osteoporosis in motion
    • Phytotherapie
    • Practice Management
      • Aargau Cantonal Bank
      • Claraspital
    • Psychiatry
      • Geriatric Psychiatry
    • Rheumatology
  • Departments
    • Fachbereiche 1-13
      • Allergology and clinical immunology
      • General Internal Medicine
      • Anesthesiology
      • Angiology
      • Surgery
      • Dermatology and venereology
      • Endocrinology and Diabetology
      • Nutrition
      • Gastroenterology and Hepatology
      • Genetics
      • Geriatrics
      • Gynecology
      • Hematology
    • Fachbereiche 14-26
      • Infectiology
      • Cardiology
      • Nephrology
      • Neurology
      • Emergency and intensive care medicine
      • Nuclear Medicine
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • ORL
      • Orthopedics
      • Pediatrics
      • Pharmacology and toxicology
      • Pharmaceutical medicine
    • Fachbereiche 26-38
      • Phlebology
      • Physical medicine and rehabilitation
      • Phytotherapy
      • Pneumology
      • Prevention and health care
      • Psychiatry and psychotherapy
      • Radiology
      • Forensic Medicine
      • Rheumatology
      • Sports Medicine
      • Traumatology and trauma surgery
      • Tropical and travel medicine
      • Urology
      • Dentistry
  • CME & Congresses
    • CME continuing education
    • Congress Reports
    • Congress calendar
  • Practice
    • Noctimed
    • Practice Management
    • Jobs
    • Interviews
Login

Sie haben noch keinen Account? Registrieren

  • Guidelines in medicine

Legally binding or just a recommendation?

    • Congress Reports
    • Psychiatry and psychotherapy
    • RX
  • 4 minute read

Treatment recommendations and guidelines offer the possibility of rapid acquisition of current and practice-relevant knowledge, make decision-making more transparent for physician and patient, and provide guidance for treatment with regard to ethical, legal, and medical aspects. However, they are in no way a substitute for ongoing education or even a viable doctor-patient relationship.

In his presentation at this year’s Swiss Forum for Mood and Anxiety Disorders of the Swiss Society for Anxiety and Depression (SGAD), Zurich, Prof. Paul Hoff, MD, addressed the general aspects of guidelines in medicine and specifically in psychiatry. Guidelines are a core component of evidence-based medicine (EBM) and are currently a topic of very broad and, in part, controversial discussion throughout the medical community. In the context of EBM, evidence is the result of systematic evaluation of published results of scientific studies. “That is, EBM is a rationally reviewed and verifiable form of current scientific knowledge, not the personal opinion of an eminence,” Prof. Hoff explained. It is often forgotten that EBM is a continuous process and not a final outcome. One of the best-known databases of evidence-based information is the Cochrane Library. Here, anyone interested can find robust data material on the treatment of a specific disease.

Guideline – Guideline – Treatment recommendation?

Guideline, guideline and treatment recommendation differ in their – partly also legal – binding force and thus also in the decision-making scope of the physician who applies them. The narrowest version is the directive, which is to be understood as a regulation in the administrative field, for example, and must therefore be taken into account. Guidelines, on the other hand, are recommendations and differ in principle only in terms of language from treatment recommendations. “Although the guidelines issued by the Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences (SAMS) are not legally binding and do not have the force of law, they are slowly entering the realm that lawyers call soft law.” Soft law is not a law that is mandatory to consider and therefore enforceable, but soft law can cause problems if it is not considered and something happens. With the discussion about guidelines, we are therefore also entering a legal area,” Prof. Hoff pointed out.

In medicine, guidelines generally create the possibility for rapid acquisition and thus also application of current and practice-relevant knowledge. On the other hand, many colleagues fear that the individual character of the treatment process could be lost through guidelines and that the medical identity with freedom of treatment and the usually quite large scope could increasingly change negatively in the direction of regimentation and technocracy.

Guidelines in psychiatry

Also with regard to the use of guidelines specifically in psychiatry, the spectrum of arguments for and against is very wide (Tab. 1) . The advantages of guidelines include better transparency of decision-making for physicians and patients. Prof. Hoff gave an example: “Especially in acute psychiatry, where we often have to deal with particularly delicate situations, such as FU (fürsorgerische Unterbringung [since 1.1.13 instead of FFE; editor’s note]) of hectic, agitated psychosis patients, etc., the reference to a guideline and a consensus of experts can be very helpful when talking to the patient.” Guidelines promote the transfer of research into practice, are helpful in informing the patient and justifying treatment (ethical duty), and can additionally be a legal safeguard. Finally, guidelines are very well suited for education, training and continuing education.

On the other hand, in the context of guidelines, one must be aware that the transformation from scientific publication to evaluated evidence, i.e., to guideline, is a very complex, multifaceted, and often confusing process. Further, not only facts but also evaluated facts are taken into account. According to Prof. Hoff, various authors also point out that subthreshold psychiatric morbidity may be underestimated in operational guidelines. “In terms of whether or not a patient who doesn’t meet the criteria for a diagnosis right now but is unwell is sick and needs to be treated, experience often helps more than the guidelines and you may still need to treat the patient.”

Another important point is the fact that there are no data on many treatments, especially, for example, on multimedication, which is often used in clinical practice. “However, this does not mean that these treatments do not work. ‘No data’ does not mean ‘no effect’!”, Prof. Hoff emphasized. Guidelines and operational diagnostic manuals cannot practically take into account the individual values of the individual patient, but the latter nevertheless plays an important role in everyday clinical practice and must be taken into account. Finally, one must always be aware that meta-analyses, which serve as a basis for guidelines, have their methodological limitations: All studies can never be included, the selection criteria of the individual studies are often very different, and negative results are often not published at all and thus cannot be considered in a meta-analysis. Furthermore, study results can often only be generalized to a limited extent. It is also important to distinguish between efficacy and effectiveness. The efficacy demonstrated in the study is not necessarily identical with the effectiveness in practice and clinic.

Conclusion

  • Guidelines are modifiable, highly methodological elements of the examination and treatment process. They are useful tools, but not laws, dogmas or worldviews.
  • The task of the guidelines is – quite pragmatically – to reduce the probability of errors.
  • Guidelines can be misunderstood, even misused. They may limit the physician’s and patient’s scope for decision-making quantitatively, but not qualitatively.
  • Whether medical guidelines are experienced as a pleasure or a frustration depends largely on the self-image of the professional who uses them.
  • Guidelines are useful tools, but they are no substitute for continuing education or even for a viable physician-patient relationship.

Source:4th Swiss Forum for Mood and Anxiety Disorders (SFMAD), Zurich, April 18, 2013.

Autoren
  • Dr. med. Sabina M. Ludin
Publikation
  • InFo NEUROLOGIE & PSYCHIATRIE
Related Topics
  • Cochrane
  • EBM
  • Effectiveness
  • Efficacy
  • evidence-based medicine
  • Guideline
  • Guidelines
  • Multimedication
  • SGAD
  • Treatment recommendation
Previous Article
  • Thrombosis risk with the pill

Which pill should you prescribe?

  • Education
  • Gynecology
  • Prevention and health care
  • RX
View Post
Next Article
  • Lipid Management

Current practice and future treatment options

  • Cardiology
  • Education
  • RX
View Post
You May Also Like
View Post
  • 6 min
  • Case Report

Breast cancer metastases in the bladder

    • Cases
    • Education
    • Gynecology
    • Oncology
    • RX
    • Urology
View Post
  • 11 min
  • Findings from the ALS Symposium 2024 in Montreal

Current and future approaches in the treatment of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)

    • Congress Reports
    • Interviews
    • Neurology
    • RX
    • Studies
View Post
  • 8 min
  • Efficacy, mechanism of action and clinical effects

Garlic and high blood pressure

    • Cardiology
    • Education
    • General Internal Medicine
    • Pharmaceutical medicine
    • Phytotherapy
    • RX
    • Studies
View Post
  • 7 min
  • Moderate to severe chronic hand eczema

Delgocitinib cream – first topical pan-JAK inhibitor approved in Switzerland

    • Allergology and clinical immunology
    • Dermatology and venereology
    • Education
    • Infectiology
    • Market & Medicine
    • Pharmacology and toxicology
    • RX
View Post
  • 9 min
  • Wild-type transthyretin amyloid cardiomyopathy (ATTRwt-CA)

Diagnosis at an early stage, prognostic classifications and outlook

    • Cardiology
    • Education
    • RX
    • Studies
View Post
  • 4 min
  • Case report: Drug-induced hepatitis

Rare side effect of tirzepatide therapy

    • Cases
    • Education
    • Endocrinology and Diabetology
    • Gastroenterology and Hepatology
    • Pharmacology and toxicology
    • RX
    • Studies
View Post
  • 4 min
  • Plea for sex-specific neurology

Migraine in men: underdiagnosed, underestimated, under-researched

    • Education
    • Neurology
    • RX
    • Studies
View Post
  • 4 min
  • Prurigo nodularis

Retrospective analyses of large data sets from everyday practice

    • Allergology and clinical immunology
    • Congress Reports
    • Dermatology and venereology
    • RX
Top Partner Content
  • Forum Gastroenterology

    Zum Thema
  • Herpes zoster

    Zum Thema
  • Dermatology News

    Zum Thema
Top CME content
  • 1
    Patience, knowledge and persistence in therapy
  • 2
    Sarcopenia and malnutrition in the context of pneumological rehabilitation
  • 3
    Medical and psychosocial perspectives
  • 4
    New nomenclature for non-alcoholic fatty liver disease
  • 5
    Examinations and considerations before therapy

Newsletter

Sign up and stay up to date

Subscribe
Medizinonline
  • Contact
  • General terms and conditions
  • Imprint

Input your search keywords and press Enter.